Even Mighty Amazon Can’t Deliver on Grocery Delivery
by David Randolph, 15 Aug 2018
I tested Amazon’s grocery delivery service this past weekend and I’m left with the following thoughts:
- Clunky shopping and product selection
- AmazonFresh & Whole Foods confuses shoppers
- Significant price premium
- Complicated delivery
- Wasteful packaging
For now, traditional grocery has nothing to fear. But I will say, if any company can figure out a way to deliver groceries smoothly, it will be Amazon.
Despite the segment being a famously low margin retail business, retail giants want your grocery dollar. Target and Walmart have proliferated while Costco has enjoyed remarkable success with grocery bulk sales. In the midst of all this, Kroger has quietly grown into the second largest retailer in America, but the key event is the acquisition of yuppie grocer Whole Foods — recently snapped up by Amazon.
Amazon acquired Whole Foods for its meticulously chosen, upscale and urban real estate. Whole Foods’ locations will become excellent “last mile” distribution points for the online giant. Amazon will also bring Prime membership into Whole Foods, further penetrating into the other half of American households that don’t subscribe to Prime.
But, the real value is data. Our purchases of household products and food items paint a robust picture of our homes. Building algorithms that predict future behavior, based on recording almost everything we buy today, is data that not even Google, Facebook or Experian can gather.
Product Selection is Clunky
Let’s unpack the consumer experience of Amazon’s grocery delivery service with the first problem — the shopping experience is not smooth. Ironically, the selection pales in comparison to an average Kroger store. Pinto beans? One brand. Parmesan cheese wedge? One brand. Plus, fresh produce is tough to wrap your head around — how much broccoli am I actually ordering? It is clunky and time consuming to go through a shopping list while looking at tiny little photos.
One measly parmesan wedge to choose from?
I used a full sized PC browser (not a phone) to shop for my grocery products. The screen real estate was very much needed. With time, I’m sure this will become more intuitive, but online grocery suffers from the same drawback as any ecommerce experience — you can’t see and touch items. Of course, this isn’t the hurdle for grocery that ecommerce is for clothing. The sheer tonnage of fresh broccoli that showed up is laughable… nobody needs that much broccoli.
AmazonFresh or Whole Foods?
Which brand is it? As I searched/selected products, Amazon annoyingly filled two carts - one for AmazonFresh and another for Whole Foods delivery. It was unclear during the shopping experience that this was happening.
I rang up $54 worth of stuff, but neither cart met the order minimum, and couldn’t be combined. I also found that items in the Amazon cart weren’t available from Whole Foods and vice versa. I ended up deleting the AmazonFresh items. My guess is that the items were coming from different local distribution centers and I’m sure this will be fixed someday.
Watch out for items not available at Whole Foods - a new cart gets created.
Amazon understands better than any other retailer, the appeal of “consumer convenience” due to “human sloth” as restaurant and meals-to-go business continues its upswing. The convenience factor requires a premium, but it also will create a nagging feeling in consumer minds.
I didn’t invest the time into item-level price comparisons (to Kroger), but the prices felt significantly higher, 25-40% higher perhaps? Ordering grocery feels like an occasional thing, not a replacement for the big weekly Kroger run. Price premium is a barrier to regular usage.
Kudos to Amazon for keeping tabs on my order progress. As it was picked and bagged, Amazon kept me informed with texts; it took almost three hours to arrive, when I was promised two hours. I was also puzzled to see my order generating from a much further Whole Foods location from my house (rather than my usual store). This long delay means that online grocery requires time schedule planning - it’s not a whim.
The driver leaves your products at the door. Since we live in a house, this isn’t an issue, but a large percentage of Americans live in condos and apartments. For the sake of collecting your groceries safely, as well as ensuring your perishables stay cold, plan to be home when the driver arrives. This is in stark contrast to traditional Amazon deliveries that can safely sit by the door for hours when nobody’s home.
AmazonFresh was preceded by several failed grocery startups.
Delivery logistics doomed Webvan, which followed the traditional approach of capital investments into trucks and employee drivers. But we are in the age of Uber, the ride-sharing pioneer has been a catalyst for the growing “gig economy” which crowd-sources labor and vehicles. My Amazon grocery delivery was almost certainly delivered by a freelance driver.
To make this point, I will channel both Al Gore and Warren Buffet. The “bags” containing my groceries were indestructible sealed pouches. My cold items were in an even heavier pouch with a space age insulation layer.
And I thought the thin Kroger plastic bags were bad for the environment?
These Amazon pouches went straight into the trash can (thus into the landfill). I could hear Mother Nature crying in anticipation of the millions of AmazonFresh orders in the coming years. These are almost a Blue Apron level of environmental impact.
Beyond nature, these also hurt your wallet. The packaging must surely play a part in the premium pricing. AmazonFresh is so intent on making a good first impression, that it over engineered the bulky delivery pouches; and it displays the true challenge Amazon faces with grocery delivery.
Amazon wants to make grocery delivery work in the U.S. and is willing to throw billions into the enterprise. Marketers should keep in mind that Amazon is certainly facing headwinds in building this into a viable Kroger killer, but infrastructure geniuses can’t solve everything.
We are talking about the complexity of a FedEx delivery business that’s even too fast-moving for FedEx. Groceries are perishable and heavy, and most importantly, this whole grocery business is low-margin even when the customer does the picking and transporting.
As a heavy Amazon shopper, I’m in no hurry to place another grocery order, but I sure do love the 5% cashback on my Chase Amazon Visa at Whole Foods. Just as Amazon planned, there are many facets to the Whole Foods acquisition, and many more in development.
In 2015, John Mackey, CEO of Whole Foods, claimed that Amazon’s entrance into grocery would be its Waterloo. Only time will tell…
Happy shopping! Want to reach out with your experience?Contact us!
Get updates; just enter your email below. Simple as that.
Content Tells. Direct Sells.
by Rosann Bartle, 21 Feb 2019
Behind the Click: Five Cognitive Biases That Drive Action
by Michelle Gunn, PhD, 12 Feb 2019
The Real Game: Google vs. Microsoft
by Jana Ferguson, 05 Feb 2019
Did the Super Bowl Ads Live Up to the Hype?
by Steve Steger, 05 Feb 2019
Super Bowl Quick Takes
by Lesley Goldberg, 05 Feb 2019
Ten Emails I’m Glad I Didn't Have to Read Last Month
by Stephen Steger, 28 Jan 2019
The Top Three Tips to Make You King of the SERP This Black Friday and Cyber Monday
by Margaret Davis, 20 Nov 2018
Voice applications and natural language are bigger than the kitchen.
by Bryan Knouse, 29 Oct 2018
Are you ready for Amazon advertising?
by Debra Wang, 25 Oct 2018
Google’s ready for Its face-lift
by DRUM Media, 25 Jul 2018
Why it’s important to invest in non-branded paid search
by Kelsey Chadwick, 27 Jun 2018
Why paid search should be your go-to media
by Katherine Jianas, 18 Jun 2018
Why Facebook’s Cambridge Analytica scandal makes me thrilled for the future of content marketing
by Ben Heiser, 21 May 2018
YouTube for Nonprofits
by Virginia Doty, 15 May 2018
Takeaways from MarTech 2018
by Michael Cruz, Chief Content Officer, 15 May 2018
Which do your consumers prefer? Inbox or Mailbox? (Infographic)
by DRUM, 14 May 2018
Get smart with Google smart bidding
by Hailee Sosnowski, 27 Apr 2018
The amazing power of personalization
by DRUM, 19 Apr 2018
Beyond once upon a time: dialogue and the art of storytelling 2.0
by Michelle Gunn, PhD, VP/Creative Director, 17 Apr 2018
SEM 101 for Nonprofits
by Jay Reyes & Chase Bender, 12 Apr 2018
How to inspire workplace creativity
by Stephen Steger, 03 Apr 2018
Local SEO for brands and franchises: Top 3 tips from 15 SEO experts
by Greg Lee, 02 Apr 2018
Next steps for advertisers after the Cambridge Analytica Facebook breach
by Traci Hendrix, 26 Mar 2018
Are you ready for the GDPR? A guide for advertising agencies
by Jerelle Gainey and Debra Wang, 15 Mar 2018
Q&A: Experts dish on the future of paid search
by Chelsea Huston, 06 Mar 2018
Why content moments are the key to understanding content marketing
by Ben Heiser, 28 Feb 2018
Why bad advertising is a form of bad manners: lessons from a Ugandan storefront
by Scott Johnson, 20 Feb 2018
Retailers and the lower funnel trap
by David Randolph, 06 Feb 2018
What’s the body language of your content really saying?
by Zoë Courtman-Smith, 31 Jan 2018
10 things to look for in enterprise SEO software: 2018 tool review
by Greg Lee, 30 Jan 2018
The top 3 PPC marketing search engines of 2018
by Debra Wang and Vladimir Bradic, 26 Jan 2018
How new changes to Google Grant will affect your nonprofit
by Shelby Huckeba, 19 Jan 2018
Latest Giving Tuesday campaign ideas from marketing-minded nonprofits
by Adam Binkley, Jay Reyes and Ruby Wustrak, 18 Jan 2018
State of Social in 2018
by Ashley Reed, 17 Jan 2018
Top 7 posts of 2017
by Jamie Wigington, 17 Jan 2018
How should SEM experts prepare for voice search? [INFOGRAPHIC]
by DRUM, 17 Jan 2018
7 Digital trends that will change how you market in 2018
by DRUM Media, 17 Jan 2018
What advertisers need to know about Apple's intelligent tracking prevention
by Jerelle Gainey, 06 Oct 2017
Using direct mail to reactivate online customers
by Rosann Bartle, 22 Sep 2017
Bing shop ‘til you drop
by Hailee Sosnowski, 14 Aug 2017
Finding a web design process that works
by Todd Chambers, 02 Aug 2017
3 Commandments for creating incredibly engaging content
by Ben Heiser, 02 Aug 2017
Twitter ads and targeting techniques that work
by Annie Green, 27 Jul 2017
5 benefits of paid social advertising
by Karina Khemani, 14 Jul 2017
Oh snap! Snapchat just upped their ad game
by Traci Hendrix, 12 Jul 2017
Dying is easy, comedy is hard
by Scott Johnson, 10 Jul 2017
Marketing and the meteor test
by Scott Johnson, 05 Jul 2017
The value of local SEO (Even when your customers aren't)
by Gregory Lee, 23 Jun 2017
The best Facebook ad types and targeting options for driving sales
by Annie Green, 15 Jun 2017
Linking online marketing to offline consumer behavior
by Heather Roach, 08 Jun 2017
To push a nonprofit's mission, you have to push with passion
by Nicole Bendel, 05 Jun 2017
7 ways B2B marketers can find success in social media
by Traci Hendrix, 31 May 2017
Google’s data-driven attribution: what you need to know
by Kimberly Honore, 23 May 2017
The skinny on Yahoo's native search retargeting feature
by Shelby Huckeba, 15 May 2017
Why you should always include brand search in your digital strategy
by Katherine Jianas, 04 May 2017
How to use content marketing to finally unify marketing strategies
by Gregory Lee, 16 Apr 2017
5 things we learned at Google’s “Search in 2017 & Beyond” event
by Kimberly Honore, 05 Apr 2017
To sell to the ego, you gotta talk to the id.
by Zoe Courtman-Smith, 04 Apr 2017
Social listening inspires smarter business strategies
by Alicia Trahan, 03 Apr 2017
Brand safety: how programmatic partners protect our clients' brands
by Brittany Altman, 31 Mar 2017
How inactive subscribers can affect deliverability
by Billy McNair, 27 Mar 2017
5 reasons to insist on 1st party data for CRM targeting
by Samantha Halpin, 22 Mar 2017
Conversation, not content, is king
by Scott Johnson, 15 Mar 2017